Sport nationThe Premier League is considering significant changes to its profit and sustainability rules (PSR), the league’s version of financial fair play regulations. The current rules, which have been in place since 2015, allow clubs to lose up to £105 million over a three-year period. However, these regulations have come under scrutiny recently, with several clubs, including Everton and Nottingham Forest, being charged with breaching the rules.
The proposed changes would align the Premier League’s financial regulations more closely with UEFA’s new financial sustainability rules (FSR). Under UEFA’s model, clubs participating in European competitions would be limited to spending 70% of their revenue on squad costs, including wages and transfer fees. The Premier League is reportedly considering a more generous 85% squad cost ratio for clubs not playing in Europe.
Impact on Everton
Everton are currently in a precarious position, having already been deducted 10 points (reduced to six on appeal) for breaching PSR in the 2021-22 season. They are also facing a second charge for the 2022-23 season. However, football finance expert Kieran Maguire believes that Everton may fare better under the proposed new rules.
Maguire notes that Everton have made a concerted effort to reduce their wage bill by selling high-earning players like Anthony Gordon. This, combined with the revenue generated from their new stadium sponsorship deal, could put them in a stronger position going forward. Maguire predicts that Everton “would probably be on the right side of the divide for this season, and that means that going forward they’d be in a stronger position.”
However, the timing of the rule changes has drawn criticism from Everton and their supporters. The club feels that the Premier League has been “tireless in their efforts to disrupt Everton this campaign,” and that changing the rules now is essentially an admission that the previous guidelines were not fit for purpose. Everton argue that it is unfair for them to be sanctioned under the old rules while the league simultaneously moves to change them.
Impact on Newcastle and Other Ambitious Clubs
The proposed changes could also have significant implications for clubs like Newcastle United, who have ambitious plans for growth under their new Saudi-backed ownership. Newcastle’s revenue was reported to be around £250 million in 2023, which would allow them to spend up to £175 million on transfers, wages, and agent fees under the proposed 85% squad cost ratio.
However, some experts, like Dr. Rob Wilson, have expressed concerns that the new rules could make it more difficult for clubs outside the established elite to break into the top tier of the Premier League. Wilson argues that the rules “lock in existing financial advantages and gaps so in effect create a glass ceiling designed to minimise the chances of another superpower, such as Manchester City or Chelsea, being created.”
This sentiment is echoed by Newcastle, who feel that FFP is punishing them for their ambition. The club may be forced to sell key players like Bruno Guimaraes in order to comply with the regulations, despite their owners’ willingness to invest heavily in the squad. As one senior Newcastle source put it, “It’s not the willing from the owners that is preventing us from signing big players in January. It’s the rules.”
Criticism of Current FFP Rules
Many critics argue that the current FFP rules are not fit for purpose and end up harming the very clubs and supporters they were designed to protect. Everton’s case highlights how investment in infrastructure, like their new stadium, can actually count against clubs under the current regulations.
Kieran Maguire argues that “FFP is based on an arbitrary version of profit” and that “businesses go bust due to lack of cash, so it is an inconsistency to say that FFP assists clubs in terms of either achieving profitability or sustainability.” In other words, the rules do not necessarily ensure the long-term financial health of clubs, but instead serve to entrench the advantages of the established elite.
There are also concerns about the unintended consequences of FFP, such as clubs being forced to prioritize corporate clients over traditional supporters in order to generate more revenue. At Newcastle, this has led to tension between the club and its fan base, as more expensive tickets and corporate seats are seen as necessary to comply with the regulations.
The Need for Reform
As the Premier League prepares to vote on the proposed changes to its financial regulations, there is a growing sense that reform is necessary. The current rules have been criticized as unclear, outdated, and potentially harmful to the long-term health of the sport.
However, any changes must be carefully considered to ensure that they do not simply entrench the advantages of the existing elite clubs. The Premier League must strike a balance between ensuring financial sustainability and allowing for healthy competition and growth.
One potential solution is to adopt a more flexible approach to infrastructure investment, recognizing that projects like new stadiums can have long-term benefits for clubs and their communities. The league could also consider implementing a more gradual squad cost ratio, allowing clubs to adjust over time rather than facing sudden and severe restrictions.
Ultimately, the goal of any financial regulations should be to protect the integrity and competitiveness of the sport, while also ensuring the long-term sustainability of its clubs. The Premier League has an opportunity to lead the way in this regard, but it must be willing to listen to the concerns of all its stakeholders and adapt its approach as necessary.
Conclusion
The proposed changes to the Premier League’s financial regulations have the potential to significantly impact clubs like Everton and Newcastle, as well as the competitive balance of the league as a whole. While the intention behind the changes is to align with UEFA’s rules and ensure greater financial sustainability, there are valid concerns about unintended consequences and the entrenchment of existing advantages.
As the Premier League considers these changes, it must engage in a transparent and inclusive process that takes into account the perspectives of all its clubs and supporters. Only by striking the right balance between financial responsibility and competitive fairness can the league ensure the long-term health and vitality of English football.
The cases of Everton and Newcastle serve as cautionary tales, highlighting the complex challenges faced by clubs in the modern game. While financial regulations are necessary to prevent reckless spending and ensure stability, they must be designed and implemented in a way that allows for healthy growth and competition.
As the football world watches closely, the Premier League has an opportunity to set a new standard for financial sustainability and competitive balance. By learning from the mistakes of the past and embracing a more flexible and adaptive approach, the league can chart a course towards a brighter future for all its clubs and supporters.
Citations:
[1] https://theathletic.com/5198425/2024/01/13/premier-league-ffp-financial-fair-play/
[2] https://www.goodisonnews.com/2024/03/12/everton-risk-under-new-premier-league-spending-rules-analysed-by-finance-expert-kieran-maguire/
[3] https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11095/13041990/premier-league-financial-fair-play-rules-explained-what-restrictions-are-there-on-clubs-spending-what-they-want
[4] https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11661/13048863/everton-and-nottingham-forest-charged-with-breaching-premier-league-profitability-and-sustainability-rules
[5] https://www.football.london/chelsea-fc/news/finance-expert-chelsea-man-city-28139544
[6] https://inews.co.uk/sport/football/premier-league-ffp-rules-chelsea-newcastle-aston-villa-2951647
[7] https://www.sportingnews.com/us/soccer/news/premier-league-profit-sustainability-rules-financial-fair-play/42ef3c1a91043e191482250d
[8] https://eplindex.com/98899/kieran-maguire-multi-club-legal-storm-brews-for-everton.html
[9] https://www.football.london/arsenal-fc/news/premier-league-executive-concern-over-28813996
[10] https://theathletic.com/5203898/2024/01/15/everton-psr-breach-points-deduction-explained/
[11] https://www.footballinsider247.com/kieran-maguire-drops-man-city-prediction-for-115-charges-after-everton-complaints/
[12] https://cominghomenewcastle.sbnation.com/2024/2/8/24064428/premier-league-to-apply-changes-to-profit-and-sustainability-rules
[13] https://inews.co.uk/sport/football/everton-ffp-appeal-prediction-2901634
[14] https://news.liverpool.ac.uk/2023/11/21/evertons-ten-point-deduction-explained/
[15] https://onefootball.com/en/news/premier-league-charge-everton-and-nottingham-forest-over-ffp-breaches-38879173
[16] https://www.goodisonnews.com/2024/03/01/kieran-maguire-shares-admission-on-everton-second-ffp-charge-as-premier-league-sets-benchmark/
[17] https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/everton-points-deduction-premier-league-ffp-b2478948.html
[18] https://worldsoccertalk.com/news/verdict-on-everton-ffp-violations-may-take-4-years-to-complete-20230601-WST-435688.html
[19] https://www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/everton-sanction-premier-leagues-way-limiting-regulators-power-experts-2023-11-17/
[20] https://inews.co.uk/sport/football/ffp-rules-newcastle-punished-ambition-2847110
Sport nation
Sport Nation 2