Time to go: Everton must now cash in on £25m flop who earns 155% more than Garner

Everton’s financial challenges have been a significant talking point over recent years, particularly with the club’s struggles to align with the Premier League’s financial regulations amidst their new stadium development. These financial constraints have limited manager Sean Dyche’s ability to make significant signings, pushing the club to find ways to reduce its financial burden.

Despite a six-point deduction earlier in the season, Everton has managed to maintain a position above the relegation zone, thanks in part to strategic signings and the utilization of free agents. Players like James Garner and James Tarkowski have been instrumental in Everton’s fight for Premier League survival.

However, one player who has not lived up to expectations is Ben Godfrey. Since his £25 million transfer from Norwich City in October 2020, Godfrey’s performance and contribution to the team have dwindled. Initially seen as a significant acquisition, his appearances and playing time have decreased over the seasons.

Godfrey’s Premier League appearances for Everton have seen a steady decline from 31 in the 2020/21 season to just 9 in the current 2023/24 season. This reduction in playing time, coupled with his substantial weekly wage of £76,000, which is significantly higher than key midfielder James Garner’s £30,000, has led to discussions about his future at Goodison Park.

Given the financial pressures facing Everton and Godfrey’s diminishing role in the squad, it may be time for the club to consider selling him. This move could help Everton recoup some of their initial investment and alleviate their wage bill, potentially saving the club around £4 million annually.

Godfrey, now 26, finds himself as the third-choice centre-back under Dyche, behind preferred options like Branthwaite and Tarkowski. With just one year left on his contract and his form not matching his earlier promise, a departure could benefit both parties. For Everton, it’s an opportunity to address their financial Fair Play concerns, and for Godfrey, a chance to rejuvenate his career elsewhere.

Everton’s situation requires tough decisions, and moving on from players like Godfrey, who command high wages but offer limited on-field contributions, might be a necessary step. As the club navigates its financial challenges, such decisions could prove crucial in ensuring Everton’s sustainability and competitiveness in the Premier League.

For more insights and updates on Everton and Premier League football, subscribe to our newsletter.

• PREMIER LEAGUE
• EVERTON
• BEN GODFREY
• JAMES GARNER
• WAGE BURNERS