It’s lack of transparency…”- Bobby Madden Slams Celtic Penalty Decision again, Citing Foreign Referee’s Verdict as Proof of Error and laments the lack of transparency while changing rules

The Opening Weekend of the Premiership: A Comprehensive Review of the Big Decisions

The Premiership returned with a bang, bringing with it the usual dose of drama, controversy, and debate. The opening weekend saw several contentious decisions that sparked heated discussions among fans, players, and officials alike. Former top referee Bobby Madden took to his Instagram page to share his expert analysis on four of the biggest decisions, shedding light on the complexities of the game and the challenges faced by referees.

Madden’s first point of discussion was the alleged handball by Connor Barron against Hearts. The incident sparked debate, with some calling for a penalty and others arguing that it was not a handball. Madden’s verdict was that the correct decision was made not to award a penalty. He explained that the distance between the ball and Barron’s hand was short, and the movement wasn’t unnatural, making it not punishable under the new UEFA guidance on handball decisions.

However, Madden expressed frustration at the lack of transparency from the Scottish Football Association (SFA) regarding the new guidance. He argued that the SFA should have shared examples and explanations with fans and officials to avoid confusion and uncertainty. This lack of clarity has led to inconsistent decision-making, making it challenging for referees to make accurate calls.

The second decision Madden analyzed was the penalty conceded by Dundee United in the Dundee derby. The on-field referee initially didn’t award a penalty, but after a VAR review, the decision was overturned, and a penalty was awarded. Madden agreed with the final decision, stating that the foul was clear and the VAR intervention was correct. He praised the assistant referee for delaying the flag and allowing the play to develop, ultimately leading to the correct decision.

Madden also highlighted the importance of VAR in modern football. He argued that VAR has improved the accuracy of decision-making, but it’s not a silver bullet. He emphasized that VAR should be used to support referees, not replace them. Madden also called for more transparency in VAR decisions, suggesting that fans and officials should be able to see the footage used to make VAR decisions.

The third incident Madden discussed was Luke Graham’s alleged handball in the Dundee derby. Madden believed that the wrong decision was made not to award a penalty, as the ball traveled a long way and struck the defender’s outstretched elbow. He argued that this would have been a penalty last season and, after consulting with foreign referees, believes it should still be a penalty this season.

Madden also touched on the issue of consistency in decision-making. He argued that referees need clear guidance and support to make accurate calls. He suggested that the SFA should provide more training and resources for referees to help them understand the rules and regulations.

The final decision Madden reviewed was the non-penalty awarded to Kyogo against Kilmarnock. Madden was adamant that the wrong decision was made, as Kyogo was clearly taken out by the Kilmarnock keeper. He argued that this was a clear penalty and that the VAR should have intervened to correct the on-field decision.

Madden’s analysis sparked a lively debate among fans and officials. Some agreed with his assessments, while others disagreed. However, one thing was clear: the need for transparency and consistency in decision-making is crucial. The SFA must take heed of Madden’s call and provide more clarity and support for referees.

In conclusion, the opening weekend of the Premiership was marked by controversy and debate, with several contentious decisions sparking heated discussions. Bobby Madden’s expert analysis shed light on the complexities of the game and the challenges faced by referees. His call for transparency and consistency in decision-making is a crucial one, and the SFA must take action to ensure that the game is fair and enjoyable for all.