West Ham United is reportedly considering a move for experienced free agent Joël Matip, potentially addressing defensive issues under manager Julen Lopetegui. With only one win from four games this season, West Ham’s start has been underwhelming, despite substantial investments in the squad during the summer transfer window. A recent 1-1 draw against Fulham raised further concerns about the team’s defense, prompting the club to explore the free-agent market to add depth.
Matip, a former Liverpool defender, has emerged as a potential target. Having suffered an ACL injury last December, he is just recovering and currently a free agent, available to sign outside of the transfer window. However, concerns linger over whether the 33-year-old can still perform at the required level, given the severity of his recent injury and his age. While an ACL injury is no longer the career-threatening setback it once was, recovery can be unpredictable, particularly for older players.
One of the main arguments against signing Matip revolves around whether he can regain his form and fitness after such a significant injury. Even with no transfer fee involved, Matip’s wages could still be a significant investment. If he cannot return to his best, it could be seen as a gamble that doesn’t pay off. For West Ham, who are struggling to find consistency in defense, signing Matip would only make sense if he is capable of making a tangible impact.
The biggest question for Lopetegui is what exactly he hopes Matip can bring to the team. The manager is likely concerned about the performance of Konstantinos Mavropanos, who has been somewhat inconsistent in his recent displays. While Mavropanos is solid in many areas of his game, he struggles with short-distance acceleration, which has left him vulnerable to quick strikers. This issue was highlighted in the match against Fulham when Raúl Jiménez easily gained half a yard on Mavropanos to score the opening goal. There was also a moment when Mavropanos clumsily challenged Adama Traoré in the box, and he was fortunate not to concede a penalty after a review from VAR.
Mavropanos’ lack of speed and occasional lapses in concentration may not be fatal flaws, but they pose significant problems for West Ham in high-pressure situations. Against top-level opposition in the Premier League, such issues can lead to goals being conceded. Lopetegui must decide if Matip, who is also not particularly quick, would be an upgrade or simply another player with similar weaknesses.
During his time at Liverpool, Matip was known for his positional awareness and technical ability rather than his speed. His experience and footballing intelligence allowed him to compensate for his lack of pace, and he became a reliable figure in Jürgen Klopp’s defense when fully fit. However, Matip also had occasional lapses in judgment, and those moments of inattention could be costly. If Lopetegui is hoping to plug gaps in the defense with a player who can keep up with faster forwards, Matip might not be the perfect fit.
Another factor to consider is why Jean-Clair Todibo, a player who could bring speed and energy to the backline, has not been playing regularly. Todibo’s brief appearance against Bournemouth in the EFL Cup second round did little to impress. He looked off the pace and appeared to lack match fitness. This could explain why Lopetegui has hesitated to play him more frequently, despite his potential to address the specific problems Mavropanos faces. If Todibo is not fully ready for regular action, bringing in Matip could be a temporary solution, adding experience and much-needed depth to the squad.
West Ham’s defensive options are limited. Beyond Mavropanos and Todibo, the club only has one other senior center-back available in Max Kilman, who joined during the summer. With Kurt Zouma and Nayef Agüerd both sent out on loan and Angelo Ogbonna no longer at the club, West Ham finds itself in a precarious position at the back. The current defensive roster is not robust enough to cope with injuries or dips in form, making the potential addition of Matip more attractive.
For Lopetegui, the decision to sign Matip will likely hinge on whether the medical team is confident in the player’s fitness. If Matip passes physical tests and shows that he has fully recovered from his ACL injury, he could provide a stabilizing influence in the heart of the defense. His wealth of experience, both in the Premier League and on the European stage, could be invaluable to West Ham’s defense, particularly if Mavropanos’ inconsistencies continue or if Todibo takes longer than expected to reach peak condition.
However, if Matip’s fitness is in doubt, his arrival could simply add another layer of uncertainty to an already fragile defense. West Ham cannot afford to sign a player who is not fully capable of contributing from the outset, especially given the team’s slow start to the season. The risk of Matip being unable to handle the demands of the Premier League at his current age, particularly after a serious injury, could outweigh the potential benefits of signing him.
Ultimately, the decision to bring in Matip boils down to necessity. West Ham are short on defensive options, and the club cannot risk further defensive mishaps if they hope to improve their fortunes this season. Matip’s pedigree is undeniable, but whether he can still perform at the highest level remains an open question. Should West Ham choose to gamble on Matip, it will be with the hope that his experience and defensive nous outweigh any lingering concerns over his fitness. If he can stay healthy and return to form, Matip could prove to be a valuable addition to West Ham’s defensive line.