Sport Nation 2Former Liverpool midfielder Danny Murphy recently expressed doubts about Manchester United’s ability to compete for the Premier League title this season. According to Murphy, the Red Devils will struggle to secure a top-four finish, let alone challenge for the title. His comments follow Manchester United’s goalless draw against Crystal Palace, which has left them 11th in the Premier League standings after five games.
In contrast, West Ham United has enjoyed a much stronger start to the season, defying expectations and showing that they could be serious contenders for a top-four spot. A comparison of the two teams’ current form and squad depth reveals interesting dynamics, with West Ham positioned to potentially finish the season stronger than Manchester United, despite having less star power on paper.
Manchester United’s Struggles
Murphy’s concerns about Manchester United focus on their lack of offensive firepower and consistency in performances. The team has struggled to find the back of the net, with just two wins from five games. Murphy specifically mentioned the signing of young forward Joshua Zirkzee, who, while promising, is not a proven goal scorer. “They brought in Zirkzee, the only attacking player. He’s a young lad. He’s not a goal scorer. He is not really a center-forward,” Murphy stated.
Murphy believes Manchester United’s inability to add a reliable striker will hinder their chances of competing for the top spots. “That is not going to get Manchester United where they want to be in terms of competing for the title, even top four I think they are going to struggle,” he added.
In contrast, West Ham has been bolstered by some key additions to their squad, as well as consistent performances from their core players, making them a formidable team this season.
West Ham’s Strong Start and Squad Depth
Unlike Manchester United, West Ham United has started the season in impressive form. Under the management of Lopetegui, the Hammers have found a balance between solid defense and clinical attack, qualities that Manchester United currently lack. This has helped them accumulate points early in the season and climb into the top positions in the Premier League table.
West Ham’s squad depth is not as deep as Manchester United’s, but their key players have performed exceptionally well. For example, forward Michail Antonio has continued his impressive form in front of goal. In comparison, Manchester United has struggled to find a consistent goal-scoring threat, with key players like Marcus Rashford and Bruno Fernandes unable to carry the team through difficult matches.
Furthermore, West Ham’s defense has been solid, allowing fewer goals than Manchester United. Lopetegui’s tactical approach has allowed the team to control games defensively while taking their chances in attack.
Key Differences: Leadership and Tactical Balance
One key difference between Manchester United and West Ham is the level of leadership and cohesion within the squad. West Ham has a core of experienced players who have been with the team for several seasons and understand Lopetegui’s system. This has allowed them to develop a strong team chemistry and fight for each other on the pitch.
Manchester United, on the other hand, is still searching for that cohesion. The team has seen numerous managerial changes in recent years, and Erik ten Hag is still in the process of implementing his philosophy. The inconsistency in performances and lack of a clear tactical identity have left Manchester United vulnerable, especially in games against mid-table teams.
Tactically, West Ham has been more balanced, with Lopetegui setting his team up to be difficult to break down while still maintaining an attacking threat. In contrast, Manchester United’s defensive structure has been shaky, particularly with injuries to key defenders like Luke Shaw and Raphael Varane. This has resulted in United dropping points in games they were expected to win, a problem West Ham has avoided so far this season.
West Ham’s Potential for a Top-Four Finish
Given their current form, it’s reasonable to suggest that West Ham has a strong chance of finishing in the top four this season. Their early performances have shown that they are capable of competing with the Premier League’s best, and if they can maintain their consistency, they will be in the mix for a Champions League spot.
The key for West Ham will be maintaining squad fitness and continuing their strong defensive displays. Michail Antonio’s fitness will also be crucial, as he is West Ham’s primary goal-scoring threat. If Antonio can stay fit and keep scoring, combined with the creative support from players like Lucas Paquetá, and Jarrod Bowen, West Ham has all the tools to secure a top-four finish.
Murphy’s concerns about Manchester United’s top-four chances seem valid when compared to West Ham’s trajectory. While United has a more star-studded lineup, their lack of coherence and consistent attacking threat puts them at a disadvantage compared to a more organized and cohesive West Ham side. Manchester United may struggle to overtake teams like West Ham, Newcastle United, or even Brighton & Hove Albion, all of whom have started the season brightly.
West Ham’s Strong Signings and Squad Depth
West Ham’s transfer strategy has been far more productive than Manchester United’s, particularly in terms of addressing key weaknesses.
The fact that West Ham has been able to cope with the loss of a player as influential as Rice, while still improving their overall team performance, is a testament to their smart recruitment. In contrast, Manchester United’s signings have not had the same immediate impact, with questions being raised about whether they addressed their most pressing needs.
West Ham’s ability to replace key players and keep their momentum going, even in the face of tough competition, suggests that they are well-equipped to remain in the top-four conversation throughout the season.
Conclusion
Danny Murphy’s concerns about Manchester United’s ability to secure a top-four finish seem justified, especially when compared to West Ham’s strong start to the season. While Manchester United has the potential to improve once injured players return, their lack of a reliable goal scorer and defensive vulnerabilities could prevent them from finishing in the top four.
On the other hand, West Ham has shown that they are a well-organized, balanced team with a clear tactical plan. If they continue their current form, there’s every reason to believe that West Ham could end the season with a Champions League spot, surpassing the likes of Manchester United and other traditional top-four contenders.
West Ham’s success will depend on maintaining squad fitness, particularly in attack and defense, but their solid start suggests that they are more than capable of finishing the season ahead of Manchester United, and possibly several other Premier League giants.
Sport nation
Sport Nation 2
