The Unfilled Void: Everton’s Continued Struggle to Replace Ross Barkley
Ross Barkley’s departure from Everton in 2018 left a sour taste, but the lingering impact of his absence is still felt in the team’s midfield. Phil Kirkbride explores the void left by Barkley and why Everton have struggled to replace him.
A Productive Partnership
During Ross Barkley and Romelu Lukaku’s four-season stint together at Everton, they formed a deadly duo, scoring a combined 89 league goals. While Lukaku accounted for the majority, Barkley’s contributions were substantial, with 41 assists between them. The split was surprisingly even, with Barkley trailing Lukaku by only five assists.
The Unreplaced Talent
Everton’s inability to replace Lukaku’s goalscoring prowess is well-documented. However, the discussion often overlooks Barkley’s departure. Have Everton truly replaced what Barkley brought to the table?
Barkley’s Prime Years
Now 29, Barkley is in his prime. His final two seasons alongside Lukaku saw them pose a significant threat to opposing teams. Lukaku has publicly praised Barkley as his best teammate during their Goodison Park days.
Factors Behind Barkley’s Departure
A combination of factors led to Barkley’s Chelsea move. The allure of Champions League football, increased wages, and the prospect of joining a title-contending team proved too enticing.
Everton’s Midfield Conundrum
Since Barkley’s exit, Everton has struggled to find an adequate replacement. Various signings have failed to fill the creative void left by the England international.
Assessing the Options
Andre Gomes, signed in 2019, has shown flashes of brilliance but inconsistency and injuries have hindered his impact. James Rodriguez, despite initial promise, failed to replicate Barkley’s box-to-box energy.
The Search Continues
As Everton continues its pursuit of midfield reinforcements, they must consider the qualities that made Barkley invaluable:
- Creative spark
- Box-to-box energy
- Goal-scoring threat
- Vision and passing range
Lessons from the Past
Everton’s inability to replace Lukaku’s goals and Barkley’s creativity serves as a reminder of the importance of retaining key players and investing wisely in the transfer market.
Conclusion
Ross Barkley’s departure from Everton left an unfillable void in the team’s midfield. As the club continues its search for creative reinforcements, they must acknowledge the significance of Barkley’s contributions and strive to find a suitable replacement.