Where is the claim that celtic is favoured by officials: Ex-Category One referees ‘can’t really understand’ why Motherwell didn’t have another player sent off vs Celtic

Controversy Surrounds Motherwell vs Celtic Clash: Ex-Referees Weigh In

The Scottish Premiership match between Motherwell and Celtic was marred by controversy, with two contentious incidents sparking debate. Former SFA referees Des Roache and Steve Conroy have now weighed in, expressing surprise that Motherwell’s Stephen O’Donnell escaped a red card.

The Incident: O’Donnell’s Challenge on Maeda

During the match, O’Donnell’s forearm led the charge in a challenge on Celtic’s Daizen Maeda. The incident sparked outrage, with many calling for a red card. Roache and Conroy, speaking on their Behind The Whistles podcast, concurred.

“He’s [O’Donnell] ran across and led with his forearm. That’s the first contact, the forearm and barged across him,” Roache said. “I don’t genuinely believe you think Maeda has tripped the defender here.”

VAR’s Role: A Missed Opportunity

The VAR system’s failure to intervene has raised questions. Conroy noted, “VAR should see that and suggest a review of the penalty and DOGSO (Denying Goal-Scoring Opportunity) red card. They have numerous cameras.”

Motherwell’s Lucky Escape

Roache and Conroy’s assessment suggests Motherwell were fortunate to avoid a second red card. Liam Gordon’s dismissal for a horrific tackle on Adam Idah had already left the hosts reeling.

Stuart Kettlewell’s Reaction

Motherwell boss Stuart Kettlewell’s post-match comments have been criticized. Roache and Conroy’s expert analysis contradicts Kettlewell’s claims, highlighting the severity of O’Donnell’s challenge.

Celtic’s Victory: A Bittersweet Win

Brendan Rodgers’ side returned to the top of the Scottish Premiership, but the victory was overshadowed by controversy. The match officials’ decisions have sparked debate, with many calling for improved consistency.

The Bigger Picture: Celtic’s Title Bid

As Celtic prepare to face Dundee on Wednesday, the focus shifts to the title race. With Rangers trailing Aberdeen by six points, Celtic fans will be watching the Aberdeen vs Rangers match with interest.

The Fan Conundrum

Do Celtic fans want Rangers to lose, maintaining the gap between the two clubs? Or would a draw be preferable, keeping the pressure on Rangers? The answer may vary, but one thing is certain – Wednesday’s matches will have significant implications for the Scottish Premiership.

Expert Analysis: The Key Takeaways

Des Roache and Steve Conroy’s expert analysis highlights the need for improved VAR consistency and accurate decision-making.

• O’Donnell’s challenge on Maeda warranted a red card.
• VAR failed to intervene, missing a clear opportunity.
• Motherwell were fortunate to avoid a second red card.
• Stuart Kettlewell’s comments were wide of the mark.

Conclusion

The controversy surrounding Motherwell vs Celtic serves as a reminder of the importance of accurate decision-making in football. As the Scottish Premiership title race heats up, consistency will be crucial.