“It’s very clear. It’s meant to be a DISALLOWED goal…” – BBC Pundit and Former Hibernian midfielder speak on Celtic’s WIN against Motherwell, reveals the FACTS about the VAR Controversy, and what should’ve been done to Daizen Maeda…

Celtic continued their strong form with a 3-0 victory over Motherwell at Fir Park, further solidifying their position at the top of the Scottish Premiership. The match saw standout performances from Celtic players and raised discussions over a contentious VAR decision involving forward Daizen Maeda. Despite a decisive win, the penalty controversy surrounding Maeda’s disallowed goal has generated debate among fans and pundits alike.

A Commanding Performance by Celtic

Fresh off their Champions League draw with Atalanta, Celtic returned to domestic action aiming to assert their dominance. Manager Brendan Rodgers fielded a strong lineup, and the team quickly set the tone, showcasing a blend of attacking flair and defensive discipline. Fans at Fir Park witnessed a display that embodied Celtic’s ambition, as they maintained their offensive pressure against Motherwell throughout the game.

Luke McCowan, a recent addition to Celtic’s squad, opened the scoring in the first half with an impressive solo effort. McCowan evaded his marker on the edge of the box and drove a low shot past the Motherwell defense into the bottom corner. This goal further highlighted McCowan’s ability to adapt to Rodgers’ system and capitalize on scoring opportunities. His performance added to growing praise for the player, whom Rodgers had recently described as adaptable and versatile.

Missed Opportunities for Motherwell

Despite Celtic’s commanding play, Motherwell did create some early chances, particularly through young star Lennon Miller. Miller, one of Scotland’s most promising players, came close to scoring when he struck both the post and the crossbar with a powerful free-kick. However, these moments were among the few chances Motherwell could muster, as Celtic’s defense quickly regained control, minimizing any threats.

The second goal came from Celtic’s Alistair Johnston, who headed the ball into the net after the halftime break. Substitute Adam Idah later sealed the win with a tap-in following a swift counter-attack. Motherwell’s challenges were compounded late in the game when captain Liam Gordon received a red card, further diminishing their chances of a comeback.

VAR Controversy: Maeda’s Disallowed Goal

A significant talking point of the match arose in the second half when Celtic forward Daizen Maeda was involved in a controversial incident. As Maeda maneuvered towards the goal, he appeared to be shoved by Motherwell’s Stephen O’Donnell, causing him to fall and inadvertently handle the ball. The ball subsequently went into the net, but the goal was disallowed due to handball, despite what many perceived to be a clear foul by O’Donnell.

Celtic fans voiced their frustration over the decision, and VAR’s failure to award a penalty drew criticism from both the stands and football pundits. BBC pundit Michael Stewart shared the fans’ sentiment, arguing that the shove on Maeda constituted a clear foul. Stewart stated, “It was always going to be a disallowed goal, but it’s a penalty kick. I can’t for the life of me figure out how this has not been given.” He described O’Donnell’s challenge as “clumsy” and “clear as day,” emphasizing that the incident merited a penalty.

Similarly, former Hibernian midfielder Marvin Bartley echoed Stewart’s opinion, expressing confusion over VAR’s non-intervention. “I am in total agreement with that,” Bartley commented. “I don’t understand how if the referee does miss it, VAR doesn’t intervene, because that for me is a blatant penalty.”

Celtic’s Growing Confidence Ahead of Champions League Clash

With the victory over Motherwell, Celtic returned to the top of the Scottish Premiership standings, maintaining their momentum as they prepare for their next Champions League match against RB Leipzig. Celtic’s European campaign has had its ups and downs, but a recent draw against Atalanta has rekindled hopes for a strong showing in the group stage.

Their upcoming match against Leipzig, however, will not be without challenges. The Bundesliga side has been in excellent domestic form and is currently tied with Bayern Munich at the top of the German league. Leipzig’s recent 3-1 victory over Freiburg demonstrated their offensive prowess, as goals from Willi Orban, Lütsharel Geertruida, and Lois Openda secured the win. Despite Leipzig’s domestic success, they have struggled in the Champions League, suffering defeats to Atletico Madrid, Juventus, and Liverpool, which may offer Celtic an opportunity to capitalize on Leipzig’s inconsistencies.

Leipzig’s Injury Concerns Provide Potential Advantage

Celtic could benefit from Leipzig’s current injury troubles. Leipzig has announced that up to six players may be sidelined for their Champions League visit to Glasgow, with some key figures still recovering from recent setbacks. Among those doubtful are starting goalkeeper Peter Gulacsi and promising forward Luis Openda. Other potential absences include Xavi Simons, who is nursing a cruciate ligament injury, and midfielders Nicolas Seiwald, Assan Ouedraogo, and Xaver Schlager.

Despite these injury concerns, Leipzig boasts a deep squad, strengthened by significant summer investments. Their depth ensures that even with absences, they remain a formidable opponent. Nevertheless, Celtic’s strong home support at Celtic Park may give Rodgers’ side a needed boost as they face the German team.

Looking Ahead: Celtic’s Champions League Prospects

Celtic’s European journey has seen both highlights and setbacks this season. Their campaign began with a commanding 5-1 victory over Slovan Bratislava, though a subsequent 3-1 defeat to Borussia Dortmund tempered early optimism. The recent draw against Atalanta showcased Celtic’s resilience and adaptability, providing a positive lead-in to their match against Leipzig.

As they prepare for the Leipzig clash, Celtic’s domestic performance remains crucial. Brendan Rodgers has emphasized the importance of maintaining form in the Scottish Premiership, recognizing that a strong domestic foundation can bolster the team’s confidence on the European stage. Rodgers recently praised his players’ adaptability, particularly newcomers like Luke McCowan, whose recent displays have impressed fans and pundits alike.

Fan Reactions and Team Morale

Celtic supporters have shown excitement over the team’s recent performances, especially given the club’s balanced approach to both domestic and European competitions. The fans’ dedication was evident at Fir Park, and the overwhelming support has been a crucial factor in Celtic’s strong form. Amid debates over VAR and officiating, fans have rallied behind the team, underscoring their loyalty as Celtic chases both league and European success.

Rodgers’ side will need to stay focused, with the upcoming fixtures presenting both challenges and opportunities. If Celtic can capitalize on Leipzig’s vulnerabilities and maintain their Premiership momentum, the team could further strengthen their standing domestically and enhance their prospects on the European front.

Conclusion

Celtic’s dominant display against Motherwell highlights their current form and readiness to tackle both Scottish Premiership and Champions League challenges. The 3-0 victory, combined with emerging stars like Luke McCowan and the ongoing leadership of players such as Daizen Maeda, underscores the squad’s potential this season. With RB Leipzig on the horizon, Celtic has the chance to solidify their European ambitions. As they move forward, the support of their fans and the guidance of Brendan Rodgers will be pivotal in navigating the path to success across both fronts.