Sport Nation 2West Ham United’s recent 2-1 victory over Manchester United brought a much-needed boost for the Hammers, leading to the dismissal of United’s manager, Erik ten Hag. For West Ham fans, this win sparks hope for a turnaround, as the team demonstrated tactical adaptability under new manager Julen Lopetegui. However, the result also highlights underlying challenges that the club must address if they are to build on this success.
Lopetegui’s shift to a three-at-the-back formation in the second half was pivotal, surprising Manchester United and disrupting their rhythm. This adjustment allowed West Ham to bolster their defense and stifle United’s attacking options. Former player and pundit Stephen Warnock, speaking on Match of the Day 2, praised Lopetegui’s decision: “It was a really positive change from Lopetegui to alter the game. In the first half, Manchester United created a lot of opportunities. But in the second half, with five men behind the ball, it became difficult for United to break them down.”
Despite this, the formation shift may be only a temporary solution rather than a long-term fix. Lopetegui’s approach capitalized on United’s tactical struggles and the pressure surrounding Ten Hag. West Ham fans need to remain realistic, recognizing that this strategy may not work against teams with more cohesive game plans or in matches where they need to create more offensive pressure. Casemiro’s equalizer, scored despite five West Ham defenders marking him, underscored ongoing issues in their defensive setup.
Defensive Issues and Lingering Concerns
The win over United was a step forward, but it also exposed areas where West Ham must improve. Even with the additional defenders, the team’s defensive vulnerabilities were evident. West Ham’s backline struggled to handle key moments, including set-pieces, which remains a weakness. Casemiro’s goal came as he maneuvered through multiple West Ham players, highlighting lapses in concentration and organization.
Moreover, West Ham’s reliance on defensive adjustments in the face of pressure shows that they lack a solid, proactive defensive strategy. While the additional defenders in the backline helped mitigate United’s attacks, it’s questionable if this approach will work against teams with more offensive depth or a well-organized midfield. As Lopetegui seeks to build a sustainable defense, he must address these defensive gaps to avoid relying solely on formations that may not hold up against stronger opposition.
Limited Attacking Creativity
West Ham’s ongoing struggle with creativity up front remains a major concern. The lack of consistent goal-scoring opportunities has plagued the Hammers throughout the season. Players like Guido Rodriguez and Carlos Soler failed to deliver in the attack against United, leaving much of the offensive work to individual moments rather than coordinated team efforts.
The three-at-the-back system may offer temporary defensive stability, but Lopetegui must also find a way to increase the team’s attacking potency. Relying on penalties or isolated opportunities, like the one that led to Jarrod Bowen’s winning goal, won’t provide the consistency West Ham needs to compete at the top of the table. Lopetegui’s challenge lies in balancing defensive solidity with a more dynamic offense that can create consistent chances.
Lopetegui’s Task: Building a Cohesive Starting XI
One of Lopetegui’s biggest tasks moving forward is identifying a stable starting lineup and developing a cohesive playing style. West Ham’s season has seen frequent changes in tactics and personnel, which has hindered the development of a strong team identity. Finding the right balance between experienced players and emerging talent will be crucial in forming a consistent XI that can adapt to the challenges of the Premier League.
Consistency in selection could also help the players build chemistry, which is essential for any team aiming to play a high-pressure style. Lopetegui’s experience in European leagues should serve him well in making these adjustments, but time will be a crucial factor. A settled starting lineup would allow players to better understand their roles and responsibilities, minimizing the lapses that have been evident in recent matches.
Challenges Ahead: Sustainability of the Tactical Change
While Lopetegui’s tactical adjustment worked well against a struggling United side, questions remain about the sustainability of this approach. West Ham’s switch to a more defensive formation was effective in that specific context, but Premier League teams are known for their adaptability. Other clubs will quickly analyze and prepare for this strategy, and Lopetegui will need to have alternatives at his disposal.
Lopetegui’s ability to adapt his tactics against different opponents will likely define West Ham’s success this season. The manager must ensure that his tactical flexibility doesn’t lead to inconsistency or confusion among the players. Developing a core strategy that players can rely on, with slight adjustments for specific games, will give West Ham a stable foundation to build upon.
The Need for a Balanced Approach
A major takeaway from the win over Manchester United is that Lopetegui must focus on a balanced approach that doesn’t rely solely on defensive setups. While the three-at-the-back formation provided defensive stability, it limited West Ham’s ability to attack effectively. To succeed in the Premier League, Lopetegui will need to develop an approach that balances defensive resilience with offensive creativity.
Lopetegui’s Spanish roots suggest he could incorporate a style that values possession and patient buildup play. Implementing this would allow West Ham to control games more effectively, reducing their dependence on reactionary, defensive tactics. The addition of more creative playmakers or encouraging midfielders to join the attack could further boost West Ham’s offensive output, making them a more balanced team overall.
Moving Forward: The True Test of Lopetegui’s Impact
The real test for Lopetegui will come in the following weeks and months as he seeks to build on the victory over United. The Hammers have struggled with consistency all season, and a single win won’t be enough to silence doubts about the club’s potential. Lopetegui’s challenge is to use the momentum from this win to drive consistent performances across the rest of the season.
If West Ham can build on their recent success and Lopetegui can solidify his tactical approach, the Hammers could realistically aim for a strong finish in the league. However, a continued struggle for consistency would likely lead to ongoing questions about Lopetegui’s future at the club. His ability to develop a team that can compete consistently at a high level will ultimately determine his success at West Ham.
Conclusion: Hope for Improvement with Realistic Expectations
West Ham’s victory over Manchester United was a step in the right direction, giving fans reason to hope for a brighter season. However, the game also underscored the challenges that remain. Lopetegui’s tactical flexibility brought immediate benefits, but the limitations of a defensively oriented approach were also evident. West Ham’s issues with consistency, defensive organization, and attacking creativity still need to be addressed for the team to achieve lasting success.
Lopetegui’s task now is to transform this tactical adjustment into a long-term strategy that balances defensive resilience with offensive flair. His ability to foster a cohesive team identity and build on recent momentum will be key factors as he navigates the challenges of the Premier League. If he can do so, West Ham fans may indeed have cause for optimism. However, if these issues persist, questions about Lopetegui’s suitability for the role will inevitably arise, leaving West Ham searching for answers once again.
Sport nation
Amina Umar
