Sport Nation 2Celtic returned to the top of the Scottish Premiership table this weekend with a hard-fought 2-0 away victory over Kilmarnock. Goals from Callum McGregor and Nicolas Kuhn secured the win, but despite the result, it was clear that the team wasn’t at its best. The match highlighted a few concerns for manager Brendan Rodgers, as Celtic struggled to dominate in the manner they typically do in domestic matches. Kilmarnock actually outshot Celtic, registering eight more shots overall, with both teams having the same number on target.
Following the match, former Celtic striker Chris Sutton pointed out that two players, Adam Idah and Arne Engels, struggled during the game. Speaking to Sky Sports Football, Sutton expressed his disappointment in their performances and hinted at potential areas for improvement.
Adam Idah’s Difficult Afternoon
One of the players singled out by Sutton was striker Adam Idah, who recently joined Celtic on a permanent basis from Norwich City after a promising half-season loan spell. Celtic invested significantly in securing Idah, viewing him as a valuable addition to their attacking lineup. Although he has shown flashes of potential, he has yet to establish himself as a consistent presence capable of challenging the prolific Kyogo Furuhashi for a starting role.
Sutton noted that Idah appeared out of sync with the team and missed the opportunity to make a mark in this match. “It’s difficult when you aren’t starting so many games, and he hasn’t done,” Sutton remarked, pointing out the challenge for Idah to find his rhythm and confidence without consistent playing time. With Kyogo eventually brought on as a substitute, it was a clear signal that Idah had not made the impact Rodgers would have hoped for in the fixture.
For Idah, games like this are essential for proving his value and pushing for more regular inclusion in the starting lineup. Given Kyogo’s established position as the first-choice striker, Idah’s path to more minutes relies on capitalizing on his chances, especially in matches against teams like Kilmarnock. His performance in this game did little to advance his case, as he struggled to adapt to the demands of the game.
Arne Engels: Celtic’s Record Signing Faces Challenges
Another player Sutton mentioned was midfielder Arne Engels, who arrived at Celtic as the club’s record signing from FC Augsburg. Engels was brought in with high expectations to replace Matt O’Riley, and while he has shown potential, consistency remains an issue. In his limited time with Celtic, Engels has demonstrated skill and produced some promising statistics. However, those moments of quality have yet to translate into steady, impactful performances.
In the match against Kilmarnock, Engels appeared uncomfortable on the pitch, struggling to find his rhythm and adapt to the playing surface. Sutton noted, “Bernardo for Engels, who has struggled on this surface,” highlighting that Engels’ adjustment issues could be partially attributed to the field conditions. Still, Sutton’s comments reflect broader concerns about Engels’ ability to consistently deliver at the level expected of a club-record signing.
Despite his flashes of quality, Engels has not yet matched the stability and influence of players like Nicolas Kuhn or the player he was intended to replace, Matt O’Riley. Both Kuhn and O’Riley have demonstrated reliability and consistency, attributes that Engels will need to cultivate if he’s to meet the expectations set for him. Sutton’s critique emphasizes the challenge facing the young midfielder: while his skills are evident, translating them into consistent performances is the next step in his development.
The Importance of Consistency for Celtic’s Title Challenge
For Celtic, the performances of players like Idah and Engels are critical as they pursue another Scottish Premiership title. While the team remains strong overall, maintaining momentum at the top of the table will require consistent contributions from every squad member, particularly those who were brought in to strengthen key areas.
Celtic’s recent investment in players like Idah and Engels signals the club’s ambition to remain competitive both domestically and in European competitions. However, for that ambition to be realized, these players must adapt quickly and deliver when called upon. Sutton’s comments underscore the importance of consistency and the high standards expected at Celtic, particularly for new signings looking to make their mark.
Rodgers and his coaching staff will likely work closely with Idah and Engels to address the areas identified by Sutton. Both players have shown promise, and with proper guidance, they may yet become key contributors for Celtic. However, for now, the challenges they face highlight the transition required to succeed at a club with Celtic’s expectations and competitive demands.
A Look Ahead: Building on the Kilmarnock Win
Despite their struggles, Celtic’s victory over Kilmarnock allowed them to reclaim the top spot in the league, a position they’ll look to defend as the season progresses. The team’s ability to secure three points even without playing their best is a positive sign, reflecting resilience and determination. However, if Celtic is to maintain its lead and build a cushion in the standings, players like Idah and Engels will need to step up.
Looking forward, Rodgers will be keen to address the areas of concern from the Kilmarnock game and work on building greater cohesion and sharpness within the squad. For Idah, finding a way to capitalize on his opportunities is crucial. Developing his understanding of Celtic’s tactical setup and building chemistry with his teammates will be essential if he’s to push Kyogo for a more prominent role. Engels, meanwhile, will need to focus on improving his consistency and adapting to the demands of the Scottish league.
Sutton’s critique serves as a reminder of the challenges facing new players at Celtic. Adapting to the intensity and expectations of one of Scotland’s top clubs is no small feat, and while Idah and Engels have the talent to succeed, they’ll need to overcome these hurdles if they’re to become integral members of the team.
Final Thoughts: Navigating the Season’s Challenges
As Celtic prepares for the challenges that lie ahead, the club’s title aspirations hinge not only on their established stars but also on the contributions of newer additions like Idah and Engels. The club’s ambitions in both domestic and European competitions mean that depth and versatility across the squad are crucial. Each player’s ability to perform consistently will be a determining factor in Celtic’s success.
With the season underway and competition heating up, Rodgers will be focused on getting the best out of his squad and ensuring that every player is prepared to contribute when needed. For Idah and Engels, this means capitalizing on opportunities to prove their value and integrating more fully into the team’s tactical framework.
Sutton’s remarks highlight the high expectations surrounding Celtic’s players, especially those brought in to make an immediate impact. While the Kilmarnock match may not have been their best, it serves as an opportunity for reflection and growth. With the right adjustments, Idah and Engels have the potential to rise to the challenge and become key assets for Celtic as the season progresses.
Sport nation
Amina Umar