“He was Reckless and has Disregard for the opponents” – Former Referee speaks about Celtic star player’s incident with an opponent in the clash against Aberdeen; says he should be SCRUTINIZED and PENALIZED.

Celtic forward Kyogo Furuhashi faced scrutiny after an incident involving Aberdeen goalkeeper Ross Doohan during a Scottish Premiership clash at Pittodrie, which ended 1-0 in favor of the visitors. Former Premiership referee Bobby Madden described the challenge as “reckless” and suggested Kyogo should have received a yellow card.

The Incident

The clash occurred early in the game when Kyogo attempted to chase a through ball that Doohan had already secured. In his effort, Kyogo’s knee struck the goalkeeper squarely in the face, leaving Doohan dazed and requiring immediate medical attention. Despite the apparent severity of the collision, referee Don Robertson opted to issue only a free-kick without further disciplinary action.

Kyogo demonstrated sportsmanship by checking on Doohan after the collision, and the goalkeeper eventually resumed play after receiving treatment. Reo Hatate later scored the decisive goal for Celtic in the 78th minute, sealing the victory.

Referee Analysis

Bobby Madden, known for fostering debate on controversial match incidents, shared his perspective on social media. He posted a video clip of the challenge and initiated a poll asking fans whether Kyogo deserved no card, a yellow card, or a red card.

According to the poll results, 40% of respondents felt no card was necessary, 15% believed a yellow card was appropriate, and 45% thought a red card should have been issued. Madden himself sided with the minority advocating for a yellow card, explaining:

• “Reckless and shows a disregard for the opponent.”
• “Keeper has possession, and I believe there was an opportunity to avoid contact.”

Fan Reactions

The incident sparked polarized opinions among fans, with allegiance seemingly influencing perspectives. Celtic supporters largely defended Kyogo’s actions, while Aberdeen and Rangers fans argued for stricter punishment. Madden highlighted this division, observing that voting patterns reflected club loyalties.

Broader Implications

This incident underscores the fine margins in officiating high-stakes matches and the subjective nature of interpreting intent versus outcome in challenges. While Kyogo escaped further disciplinary action, debates about the consistency of refereeing decisions in Scottish football remain a contentious topic