Sport Nation 2Celtic Football Club has had its fair share of ups and downs in the transfer market, particularly when it comes to acquiring new strikers. One notable case is Patryk Klimala, who, despite early promise, struggled to make an impact at Parkhead. However, the club ultimately recouped their investment, making Klimala’s case an intriguing example of how football transfers can be unpredictable.
Klimala’s Arrival at Celtic
In January 2020, Celtic signed Patryk Klimala from Jagiellonia Białystok, a Polish club, for a fee of around £3.5 million. The 21-year-old forward was highly regarded in Poland, having progressed through Jagiellonia’s youth ranks. He had an impressive record in the club’s youth system, scoring 17 goals in just nine U19 matches. By the time of his transfer, Klimala had netted 11 goals in 50 senior appearances, including seven goals in 17 league games during the first half of the 2019/20 season.
At the time of his signing, Celtic’s manager, Neil Lennon, saw Klimala as a potential partner for star striker Odsonne Edouard. The deal was considered a coup for Celtic, as they had reportedly beaten Copenhagen to his signature by activating a €4 million release clause in Klimala’s contract. However, despite the hype surrounding his potential, Klimala’s time at Celtic would prove to be disappointing.
Struggles at Celtic
Klimala’s debut half-season at Celtic during the second half of the 2019/20 campaign was underwhelming. He managed only four appearances across all competitions and failed to score or provide an assist. This was in stark contrast to his form in Poland, where he had contributed seven goals and three assists in 17 games before his move to Glasgow.
The following season, 2020/21, was Klimala’s first full campaign at the club, and it didn’t fare much better. The young striker made 24 appearances across all competitions, scoring just three goals and providing zero assists. His performance in the Scottish Premiership was particularly underwhelming. In 17 league games, Klimala missed five clear-cut chances, a stark statistic for a player who was brought in to score goals. His overall contribution to the team was minimal, with a pass completion rate of just 68%, averaging only 2.5 passes per game.
These statistics highlighted Klimala’s struggles to adapt to the higher level of competition in Scotland, and by April 2021, Celtic decided it was time to part ways with him.
A Fortunate Sale
In what was considered a fortunate turn of events for Celtic, they managed to sell Klimala to MLS side New York Red Bulls for a reported fee of $4.8 million (£3.5 million), recouping the entirety of their initial investment. This sale came as a surprise to many, considering Klimala’s lack of impact at the club. Nevertheless, it proved to be a shrewd piece of business for Celtic, as Klimala’s career trajectory has continued to decline since his departure from Scotland.
Life After Celtic
Following his move to New York Red Bulls, Klimala enjoyed a mixed spell in the MLS. Over two seasons, he managed 14 goals and 11 assists in 63 matches, a decent return but far from the prolific form Celtic had hoped for when they signed him. His time in the MLS ended in January 2023, when he moved to Israeli side Hapoel Beer Sheva.
Klimala’s stint in Israel was similarly underwhelming. Over 23 appearances, he scored just four goals before being released by the club at the start of 2024. He then joined Polish side Slask Wroclaw on a free transfer, but his struggles continued. In 11 Ekstraklasa matches during the second half of the 2023/24 season, Klimala failed to score and missed four clear-cut chances. These performances led to his demotion to Slask Wroclaw’s second team, where he found some form, scoring four goals in four matches in Poland’s fourth division.
In September 2024, Klimala was loaned out to Australian side Sydney FC, a move that reflected his continued efforts to rediscover his form. At the age of 26, he should be entering the prime of his career, but instead, Klimala finds himself moving from club to club in search of stability.
Klimala’s Decline and Celtic’s Gain
Celtic’s decision to sell Klimala for £3.5 million has, in hindsight, proven to be a fortunate one. His career since leaving the club has been marked by inconsistency and declining market value. When Celtic sold him to New York Red Bulls, Klimala was valued at £3.5 million. Now, according to Transfermarkt, his market value has plummeted to just £500,000.
This dramatic drop in value underscores how well Celtic did to offload the striker when they did. While Klimala’s potential was evident, his inability to deliver on that promise meant that Celtic avoided a financial loss by selling him at the right time.
Lessons from the Klimala Transfer
The case of Patryk Klimala is a cautionary tale in football transfers. While clubs often invest in young players based on their potential, there is always a risk that they won’t adapt to the demands of a new league or a higher level of competition. In Klimala’s case, his promising record in Poland did not translate to success in Scotland, and Celtic’s gamble on him did not pay off on the pitch.
However, the club’s ability to recoup their investment by selling him to New York Red Bulls mitigated any financial loss. For Celtic, Klimala’s transfer ultimately became a story of how a failed signing can still result in a positive outcome, thanks to smart business decisions.
Conclusion
Patryk Klimala’s time at Celtic may have been a disappointment on the field, but off the field, the club emerged relatively unscathed by their investment. His struggles to establish himself at Parkhead, followed by his declining form in MLS, Israel, and Poland, illustrate how unpredictable football careers can be. For Klimala, the search for consistency continues, while Celtic can reflect on a transfer that, despite initial failure, ultimately worked out in their favor.
Sport nation
