“Celtic are obviously just favoured my TOP officials and nothing else?” Duk sees Celtic no goal split the pundits as ‘harsh’ Aberdeen handball sparks definitive VAR defence

Aberdeen’s Disallowed Goal Against Celtic Sparks Controversy and Pundit Debate

The highly anticipated Scottish Premiership matchup between Celtic and Aberdeen ended in a thrilling 2-2 draw, but the real talking point was the controversial disallowing of Duk’s goal for handball.

The Incident

Aberdeen defender Slobodan Rubezic met a free-kick from the left, which cannoned off Duk and beyond Kasper Schmeichel, seemingly securing a stunning comeback for Jimmy Thelin’s side. However, VAR intervened, and referee Nick Walsh’s initial decision was overturned.

Pundit Reactions

The decision sparked intense debate among pundits, with some calling it “harsh.” Billy Dodds on Red TV expressed:

“I can’t see too much in it. It will be forensic, and it will be harsh. It is the rules if it’s handball. It’s a huge decision for Celtic, it really is.”

In contrast, Pat Bonner on BBC Sportsound defended the call:

“VAR has done its job. That is the way it is. You can see the Aberdeen players are really disappointed.”

VAR Explanation

The VAR room, led by Greg Aitken, deemed the goal offside due to handball. According to the rules, any deliberate handball in the opponent’s penalty area results in a free kick. While some argued the contact was incidental, the VAR system’s precision and technology supported the decision.

Match Analysis

Celtic dominated the early stages, leading 2-0, but Aberdeen’s resilience paid off as they equalized. The disallowed goal would have sealed an incredible comeback.

Implications

The draw keeps Aberdeen second in the Scottish Premiership, level on points with Celtic. The controversy surrounding the disallowed goal will continue to spark debate.

Key Takeaways:

• Duk’s goal for Aberdeen was disallowed for handball against Celtic.
• Pundits are divided on the decision.
• VAR intervened to overturn the initial goal decision.
• The draw keeps Aberdeen second in the Scottish Premiership.

Sources:

• Daily Record
• Red TV
• BBC Sportsound
• Scottish Premiership

Would you like me to make any adjustments or changes?