“Both of them are much BETTER than Lopetegui…” – West Ham fans and BBC Sport Pundit react as Lopetegui’s REPLACEMENT surfaces online after West Ham’s loss against Tottenham.

As pressure mounts on West Ham United manager Julen Lopetegui, discussions have emerged surrounding potential replacements, with Gareth Southgate being one of the names suggested for the role. Lopetegui, who has struggled to win over the West Ham faithful, finds himself under increased scrutiny following the Hammers’ recent 4-1 defeat to Tottenham Hotspur on October 19, 2024. The heavy loss has only amplified concerns over his leadership, as fans and pundits question whether a change in management is on the horizon.

BBC Sport pundit Chris Sutton has reacted to suggestions that Southgate, or former Chelsea manager Graham Potter, could be the ideal candidates to replace Lopetegui if West Ham decide to part ways with the Spaniard. Sutton, speaking on BBC Radio Five Live’s 606 on October 19, engaged with a fan who raised the idea of Southgate or Potter stepping in to lead the East London club.

The fan expressed his view that the next few weeks would be crucial for Lopetegui, suggesting that if the team’s form doesn’t improve, West Ham should consider a managerial change. He highlighted Graham Potter and Gareth Southgate as potential candidates, stating: “I think if it doesn’t go right the next couple of weeks, you look at the likes of Graham Potter. I know Gareth Southgate said he was not going to take another job for a year or two, but all managers tend to return sooner than expected. Look at Thomas Tuchel—he was back at Bayern Munich quickly despite taking a break.”

The fan continued by comparing Lopetegui’s current struggles with his mixed track record at previous clubs: “At Wolves, Lopetegui didn’t have the best time. I know he did well at Sevilla, but at West Ham, you’d like to get somebody who has won something. While Potter hasn’t won anything, I think he has a better knowledge of the game and would do better at West Ham.”

Chris Sutton acknowledged the fan’s perspective but stopped short of endorsing the idea of Southgate or Potter as concrete solutions, saying, “Gareth Southgate and Graham Potter are possibilities, but it’s hard to say if either would be the right fit for West Ham.”

Lopetegui Under Pressure at West Ham

Julen Lopetegui, a highly respected figure in European football, was appointed as West Ham manager with high expectations. Having previously enjoyed success with Sevilla, where he won the UEFA Europa League, and a stint with Spain’s national team, his arrival was seen as a major coup for the club. However, his tenure at West Ham has been less than smooth. The recent 4-1 defeat to Spurs is just the latest in a series of underwhelming performances that have led to growing dissatisfaction among the club’s supporters.

While Lopetegui initially brought a sense of optimism to West Ham, fans are now beginning to lose patience. The team’s inconsistent form, coupled with a perceived lack of attacking flair, has raised doubts about whether the Spaniard can steer the Hammers to the heights they aspire to reach. The loss to Tottenham was particularly damaging, coming immediately after the international break when many hoped the team would return with renewed energy.

Lopetegui’s struggles are compounded by the competitive nature of the Premier League. With West Ham aiming to challenge for European spots, they cannot afford to languish in the middle of the table, and recent results have raised concerns about the club’s trajectory. Fans have voiced their frustration over the team’s lack of cohesion, with some pointing fingers at the manager’s tactics and leadership.

Is Gareth Southgate the Right Fit for West Ham?

One of the names floated as a potential replacement is Gareth Southgate, who recently stepped down from his role as England manager following Euro 2024. Southgate’s tenure with the national team saw him lead England to significant milestones, including a World Cup semi-final in 2018 and a runner-up finish at Euro 2020. However, despite his success with the national team, his style of play has often been criticized for being overly cautious, particularly in high-stakes matches.

Southgate’s connection to West Ham is speculative at this point, but the suggestion has gained traction among some fans. His experience managing at the international level could bring a level of discipline and organization to the Hammers’ squad. However, there are valid concerns regarding his club management record. Before taking over the England national team, Southgate managed Middlesbrough in the Premier League from 2006 to 2009, a stint that ended with the club’s relegation. His club-level track record pales in comparison to his international achievements, and many wonder whether he would be the right man to handle the pressures of Premier League football again.

Chris Sutton echoed these doubts, noting that while Southgate has an impressive résumé with England, his cautious tactical approach might not sit well with West Ham’s ambitions. “While Southgate has done great things with the national team, it’s not clear whether his style would suit West Ham. The fans want attacking football, and his reputation has always been one of a more defensive mindset.”

Graham Potter: A Better Fit?

Another name that has been mentioned as a potential successor to Lopetegui is Graham Potter. Unlike Southgate, Potter has built a strong reputation at the club level, particularly during his time at Brighton & Hove Albion. Known for his progressive, attacking football, Potter transformed Brighton into one of the most exciting teams in the Premier League, achieving results that exceeded expectations for a club of their stature.

Potter’s tactical flexibility and commitment to playing on the front foot have made him an attractive option for West Ham fans who are eager to see a more dynamic style of football. However, his short-lived tenure at Chelsea, where he struggled to replicate the success he enjoyed at Brighton, raises questions about whether he could handle the expectations and pressure at a larger club like West Ham.

For many supporters, Potter represents the kind of forward-thinking manager that could inject fresh energy into the squad. His ability to develop young talent and implement an attractive style of play aligns with what many West Ham fans are hoping for, especially in light of the current frustrations with Lopetegui’s more conservative approach.

What’s Next for West Ham?

For now, Lopetegui remains in charge at the London Stadium, and it is unclear whether the club’s hierarchy is actively seeking a replacement. However, with results not meeting expectations, the next few matches could be crucial for the Spaniard’s future. If West Ham’s form doesn’t improve, the calls for a change in management are likely to grow louder.

While Southgate and Potter are two potential candidates, the decision will ultimately come down to whether West Ham’s board believes a new manager can get the team back on track. As the pressure mounts, the spotlight will remain on Lopetegui to prove that he is the right man for the job. If not, the search for a new leader may begin sooner rather than later.