“…having respect and…..” Former Celtic Cocah SLAMS celtic for this WOEFUL and MANNERLESS behavior they exhibit

Martin O’Neill Weighs in on Celtic Fans’ Remembrance Day Controversy

Former Celtic manager Martin O’Neill has addressed the disruption of the minute’s silence on Remembrance Day by some Celtic fans. O’Neill emphasized the importance of respecting the moment, while also acknowledging the historical complexities surrounding the poppy and its significance for Irish republicans and nationalists.

Background: The Controversy

During Celtic’s match against Kilmarnock, a section of away fans booed and sang songs during the minute’s silence. Some supporters waved Irish and Palestinian flags and let off fireworks, prompting referee Nick Walsh to cut the silence short after just nine seconds. Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers and Kilmarnock manager Derek McInnes condemned the disruption.

O’Neill’s Perspective

Speaking on Talksport, O’Neill recognized the historical reasons behind some Celtic fans’ discomfort with Remembrance events. He explained that the poppy represents oppression for many Irish republicans and nationalists, citing the Black and Tans’ actions after World War I.

“I think there is an idea of having respect for a moment, and because it’s Kilmarnock’s home game… But this is historical. We’ve gone through this before… Young James McClean has taken a stance there, because of where he lives, and where he was brought up, and that’s completely understandable.”

James McClean’s Stance

McClean, who played under O’Neill at Sunderland, has consistently refused to wear a poppy on his jersey, citing his Irish heritage and the historical context. O’Neill commended McClean’s bravery:

“James took the stance some years ago, realizing that he was putting his career in jeopardy… He went from being a hero to being booed at home. That’s very, very difficult to take, but he took that stance. I commend James for it. He’s a brave lad.”

Troy Deeney’s Insights

Ex-Watford striker Troy Deeney discussed the issue with O’Neill, highlighting the importance of understanding different perspectives:

“Everyone’s different… Those sections of people feel that they’re entitled to do what they wanted to do because of the arguments that Martin has just laid out… I feel that wherever I go in the world, I try and respect their religion or their ways of living.”

Deeney acknowledged McClean’s approach, stating:

“He still shows a level of respect in terms of he doesn’t make any noise during the minute’s silence, and he does it in a way that I would consider is fair, but not everyone will believe that as well.”

Conclusion

The Remembrance Day controversy surrounding Celtic fans highlights the complexities of historical and cultural sensitivities. Martin O’Neill’s nuanced perspective acknowledges the importance of respect while recognizing the legitimate concerns of Irish republicans and nationalists. James McClean’s bravery in taking a stance on the issue serves as a reminder of the ongoing debates surrounding identity, history, and symbolism.

Related Topics:

Martin O’Neill
Celtic FC
James McClean
Remembrance Day
Poppy Controversy
Irish Republicans
Nationalists
Historical Context

Sources:

Talksport
PA Wire
Getty Images

Additional Sections:

Historical Context: The Black and Tans

The Black and Tans, a British paramilitary force, were deployed in Ireland during the Irish War of Independence. Their actions, including reprisal killings and destruction of property, left a lasting impact on Irish-British relations.

The Poppy Debate

The poppy has become a symbol of remembrance, but its meaning varies across cultures. For some, it represents respect for fallen soldiers; for others, it symbolizes British imperialism.

Celtic Fans’ Reaction

Celtic supporters have historically been divided on the issue. Some view the poppy as a symbol of British oppression, while others see it as a gesture of respect.

McClean’s Bravery

James McClean’s refusal to wear a poppy has sparked both praise and criticism. His stance highlights the complexities of identity, culture, and history in the context of football.

O’Neill’s Legacy

Martin O’Neill’s managerial career, including his time at Celtic, has been marked by successes and controversies. His thoughtful approach to the Remembrance Day debate demonstrates his understanding of the complexities involved.