Sport nationEverton’s Dream XI After January: Building a New Era
Everton fans have been yearning for a revival of their club’s fortunes, and with the exciting prospect of new ownership under The Friedkin Group, the hope for a brighter future feels more tangible than ever. Farhad Moshiri’s decision to sell his 94% stake could herald a transformative period, not only in terms of financial stability but also in setting new strategic directions for a club struggling to reclaim its position among the Premier League’s elite.
Currently, languishing in 16th place, Everton are once again grappling with the grim reality of a relegation battle. Sean Dyche’s team has shown flashes of improvement but remains inconsistent. While Goodison Park’s final season as Everton’s home brings nostalgia, it’s the team’s future under new management and potential January reinforcements that truly excites fans. With key positions requiring upgrades and fresh talent needed to reignite the team, here’s an in-depth look at Everton’s potential dream XI after the January transfer window.
Goalkeeper: Jordan Pickford – Everton’s Ever-Present Guardian
Jordan Pickford remains one of the few constants in Everton’s tumultuous journey over recent years. The England No. 1 has shown incredible loyalty to the club despite their struggles, and his consistent performances have often kept Everton afloat. Last season, he finished among the Premier League’s top goalkeepers, ranking second in clean sheets and third in shot-to-save percentage.
Though the defensive frailties in front of him have let him down at times, Pickford’s passion and leadership make him irreplaceable. With fresh investments in the backline potentially on the horizon, Pickford could benefit greatly from a more organized and robust defensive unit, allowing him to showcase his world-class shot-stopping skills.
Right-Back: Kieran Trippier – The Missing Creative Link
Everton’s right-back situation has been a point of concern. While Seamus Coleman has been a loyal servant, injuries and age have diminished his impact. Ashley Young, though experienced, is not a long-term solution, and Nathan Patterson has struggled to stay fit. Enter Kieran Trippier—a potential signing who could transform Everton’s flank.
Trippier, known for his crossing ability and creativity, ranks among Europe’s elite full-backs for assists and shot-creating actions. While currently at Newcastle, reports suggest he may be available due to limited game time. His addition would not only strengthen Everton’s defense but also provide a vital creative outlet, delivering dangerous balls into the box for strikers to capitalize on.
Centre-Backs: Jarrad Branthwaite and James Tarkowski – A Balance of Youth and Experience
The combination of youth and experience is crucial in building a solid defensive partnership, and Everton already possess two players capable of forming such a duo.
- Jarrad Branthwaite: After a stellar season in 2023/24, Branthwaite has emerged as one of Everton’s brightest prospects. Despite injury setbacks, his towering presence and composure on the ball make him a key figure for the future. Turning down offers from Manchester United was a bold statement of intent from the club, signaling their trust in Branthwaite to become a cornerstone of their defense.
- James Tarkowski: Signed on a free transfer from Burnley, Tarkowski has been a reliable presence in Everton’s backline. While his performances have dipped this season, he remains a leader and a physical force, winning aerial duels and organizing the defense. With better support around him, Tarkowski could regain his best form and provide the stability Everton desperately need.
Left-Back: Vitalii Mykolenko – Steady Progression
Vitalii Mykolenko’s journey at Everton has been steady rather than spectacular. While not yet a standout performer, he has shown enough potential to retain his position as the team’s first-choice left-back. With improved competition and tactical adjustments, Mykolenko could develop into a more dynamic and reliable player, capable of contributing both defensively and offensively.
Midfield: Abdoulaye Doucouré and Bryan Cristante – Experience and Control
- Abdoulaye Doucouré: Doucouré has been one of Everton’s standout performers this season. His energy, physicality, and knack for scoring crucial goals make him an indispensable part of the team. As a box-to-box midfielder, he provides the perfect balance of defensive support and attacking impetus.
- Bryan Cristante: Rumors of a potential swap deal involving Cristante and Everton’s forward Beto have generated excitement among fans. Cristante, currently at AS Roma, is a cultured midfielder with excellent passing range and tactical intelligence. His arrival could bring much-needed composure and creativity to Everton’s midfield, helping the team control games and build attacks more effectively.
Wingers: Ernest Nuamah and Iliman Ndiaye – Injecting Pace and Flair
- Ernest Nuamah: The Ghanaian winger has been on Everton’s radar for some time, and a January move seems plausible given Lyon’s financial struggles. Nuamah is a raw but electrifying talent, known for his pace and dribbling ability. At just 21 years old, he has the potential to become a Premier League star, adding unpredictability and directness to Everton’s attack.
- Iliman Ndiaye: Ndiaye has quickly become a fan favorite at Goodison Park. His flair, creativity, and ability to produce moments of magic make him one of Everton’s most exciting players since Richarlison. Pairing him with Nuamah would give Everton a dynamic and dangerous wide duo capable of unlocking defenses.
Attacking Midfielder: Dwight McNeil – The Creative Hub
Dwight McNeil’s resurgence under Sean Dyche has been a highlight of Everton’s season. With three goals and three assists in ten league appearances, McNeil has rediscovered his confidence and influence. Positioned as the team’s primary playmaker, he orchestrates attacks and provides key passes, often linking up seamlessly with the forwards.
If Everton secure reinforcements in other areas, McNeil could flourish even further, becoming the creative heartbeat of the team.
Striker: Armando Broja – A New Leading Man
With Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s contract expiring next summer and his injury record raising doubts about his long-term future, Armando Broja could emerge as Everton’s first-choice striker. Signed from Chelsea, Broja possesses the physicality and technical ability to thrive in the Premier League. Though injury has delayed his impact, he has the potential to lead Everton’s line with authority, providing a focal point for the team’s attacks.
Manager: Graham Potter – The Architect of Change
While Sean Dyche has steadied the ship, questions remain about his ability to take Everton to the next level. Graham Potter, known for his tactical acumen and emphasis on possession-based football, has been linked with the job. Potter’s appointment could signal a shift in Everton’s philosophy, aligning with The Friedkin Group’s vision for the club.
Potter’s track record at Brighton and Chelsea demonstrates his ability to develop players and implement a progressive style of play. Under his guidance, Everton could establish a more cohesive identity, capable of competing with the Premier League’s elite.
Potential Challenges and Strategic Considerations
While the prospect of assembling a dream XI is enticing, several challenges must be addressed:
- Financial Constraints: Despite the new ownership, Financial Fair Play (FFP) regulations could limit Everton’s spending. The club must balance investments in new players with offloading underperforming assets.
- Squad Harmony: Integrating multiple new signings mid-season can disrupt team dynamics. Ensuring a smooth transition will be crucial to maintaining performance levels.
- Relegation Battle: Everton must focus on securing Premier League survival before fully committing to long-term plans. Tactical pragmatism may take precedence over experimentation.
Conclusion: A New Dawn for Everton
As the January transfer window approaches, Everton find themselves at a crossroads. The combination of new ownership, potential signings, and tactical evolution offers a glimmer of hope for a club desperate to reclaim its glory days. By addressing key weaknesses and building around a core of talented players, Everton can lay the foundation for sustained success.
While the dream XI outlined here represents an ideal scenario, its realization depends on careful planning, decisive action, and a bit of luck. For Everton fans, the coming months promise to be a rollercoaster of emotions, but one thing is certain: change is on the horizon, and the Toffees are gearing up for a brighter future.
Sport nation
Sport Nation 2