Sport nationBrendan Rodgers’ Return to Celtic: A Journey Through Criticism and Triumph
Introduction: The Return of a Controversial Figure
When Brendan Rodgers returned to Celtic in 2023, his reappointment as manager came with a wave of mixed reactions. For many Celtic fans, the announcement was a surprise, even though it became clear that the club needed someone with experience and a strong footballing philosophy to fill the void left by Ange Postecoglou’s departure to Tottenham Hotspur. Rodgers, having left the club under less than ideal circumstances in 2019, had a lot to prove. His time at Leicester City had ended in disappointment, and his previous exit from Celtic still lingered in the minds of many supporters.
The situation was complicated further by the fact that Rodgers had initially been hailed as the man who brought Celtic into an era of dominance in Scottish football. Under his leadership, the club had achieved a historic treble, going unbeaten in the Scottish Premiership. However, his sudden departure for Leicester in 2019, when Celtic were still in the midst of a highly successful campaign, left many fans feeling betrayed. His reappearance as manager, therefore, required a significant period of healing, as he had to win over both the fans and the squad.
As the weeks passed, Rodgers worked to restore his reputation at Celtic, and 18 months into his second spell, the results began to speak for themselves. Celtic’s football under Rodgers once again became a source of pride, and the team’s performances, particularly in European competition, reignited the excitement that had previously existed during his first tenure.
Rodgers’ First Spell at Celtic: A Benchmark of Success
Before delving into the current state of affairs, it’s important to reflect on Rodgers’ first spell at Celtic, where he became an iconic figure in the club’s history. His tenure from 2016 to 2019 was nothing short of remarkable. During his first season, Celtic achieved the ‘Invincibles’ treble, winning the Scottish Premiership, the Scottish Cup, and the League Cup. This achievement was unprecedented in Scottish football, with the team going the entire league season unbeaten.
Rodgers’ success was not just confined to domestic competition; his team showed great promise on the European stage as well, although they faced tough opposition in the Champions League group stages. Nevertheless, the brand of football Rodgers introduced was a significant shift from Celtic’s traditional style. His emphasis on possession-based football, high pressing, and attacking play earned him praise both in Scotland and across Europe.
The pressure, however, began to mount as the seasons progressed, particularly with the demands of competing on multiple fronts and with the increasing intensity of European football. Despite his achievements, there were still criticisms regarding the team’s performance in the later stages of European competitions and the inability to retain key players, a challenge Rodgers faced towards the end of his first spell.
The Return to Celtic: New Challenges and Expectations
Rodgers’ return to Celtic was far from a simple affair. By the time he took over again, Celtic had been under the leadership of Ange Postecoglou, who had brought his own brand of football to the club, leading them to multiple trophies and steady progress in Europe. Postecoglou’s tenure was one of great success, with Celtic dominating domestically and playing an exciting brand of football, something Rodgers would have to build upon.
The fans were divided. Some saw Rodgers as the right man to bring back stability and consistency to the team, while others viewed him as a figure who had abandoned the club during a critical time in 2019. His first task was to address these lingering issues and get the fans back onside. This was no easy feat, but it was made more manageable by his experience and the success he had enjoyed in his previous stint.
Rodgers was also acutely aware of the need to improve Celtic’s standing in Europe, a goal that had been emphasized by the club’s board. Postecoglou had left the club with high expectations, particularly with regards to Celtic’s ability to make an impact in the Champions League, and Rodgers was expected to meet those standards. The Champions League group stages were seen as an important benchmark for his progress.
The 2023/24 Season: A Return to Winning Ways
By the time the 2023/24 season rolled around, Celtic had already shown signs of improvement under Rodgers. The squad, having undergone some changes, was beginning to gel under the guidance of the experienced manager. However, the pressure on Rodgers was immense. Not only did he need to continue Celtic’s dominance in Scotland, but he was also tasked with achieving success in Europe. His performance in the Champions League was especially critical, as it would play a significant role in determining the success of his second spell.
Rodgers’ squad was bolstered by a number of signings, including the likes of Arne Engels, Kasper Schmeichel, and Paulo Bernardo, among others. These additions were necessary to provide depth and quality to a squad that was somewhat stretched in terms of options. One of the key areas Rodgers focused on was strengthening the defensive unit, ensuring that Celtic could compete against stronger European opposition.
On the domestic front, Celtic continued their dominance. By the end of the season, they had secured the Scottish Premiership and the Scottish Cup, maintaining their grip on Scottish football. This success was a testament to Rodgers’ ability to maintain a competitive edge domestically, even in the face of mounting pressure.
A Strong Champions League Showing
However, it was in the Champions League that Rodgers’ Celtic truly began to shine. In what was seen as one of the most significant matches of his tenure, Celtic managed to secure a crucial victory against RB Leipzig, a match that many viewed as a turning point in Rodgers’ second spell at the club. The performance was one of the best seen in European competition for Celtic in recent years, and it highlighted Rodgers’ tactical acumen and ability to motivate his players to perform on the biggest stage.
Martin O’Neill, a former Celtic manager, was quick to praise Rodgers for his performance in Europe, particularly the win over Leipzig. Speaking to The Go Radio Football Show, O’Neill emphasized the importance of results and performances in winning over fans, stating that Rodgers’ handling of the Champions League was a significant achievement. O’Neill also highlighted how the performance against Leipzig stood out, not just for its result but for the manner in which Celtic played, asserting that it was one of the club’s best performances in Europe in recent memory.
Rodgers’ Tactical Approach: Evolution and Influence
Rodgers’ tactical approach at Celtic in his second spell has evolved somewhat compared to his first. While his commitment to possession-based football remains, he has adapted his style to suit the current squad and the demands of European football. One of the key areas Rodgers has focused on is the defensive solidity of the team, as Celtic have often struggled against high-quality European opposition. Under Rodgers, there has been an emphasis on compactness, discipline, and improving Celtic’s ability to counterattack effectively.
In midfield, Rodgers has continued to build on the work done by Postecoglou, maintaining a high tempo and pressing game, but he has also introduced more flexibility in terms of player roles. The use of versatile players like Matt O’Riley and Reo Hatate has allowed Rodgers to experiment with different tactical setups, depending on the opposition.
One of the standout players under Rodgers has been Matt O’Riley. The Danish midfielder, who had already shown promise during his first season at the club, has flourished under Rodgers’ guidance. O’Riley has been pivotal in both domestic and European fixtures, contributing with key assists and goals, as well as playing a vital role in Celtic’s buildup play.
Challenges and Criticisms
Despite the successes, Rodgers’ second spell has not been without its challenges. The criticism he received early on regarding his departure in 2019 lingered, but over time, the results have spoken louder than words. However, there are still areas of concern for both Rodgers and the Celtic fans. One of the key criticisms has been Celtic’s inconsistency in European competitions. While the victory over Leipzig was a major high, there have been other matches where the team has faltered, particularly against top-tier sides.
Moreover, Celtic’s squad depth continues to be an issue, with injuries sometimes taking a toll on the team’s performances. In particular, the departure of key players like Matt O’Riley and David Turnbull has left gaps in the squad, and while Rodgers has made some smart acquisitions, the team is still in need of further strengthening, particularly in the forward positions.
Rodgers’ Legacy at Celtic: A Manager Who Delivered
As Rodgers continues his second spell at Celtic, it is clear that his legacy at the club is being solidified. The doubters who questioned his return have been largely silenced by his ability to produce results, both in Scotland and in Europe. The challenge now is to continue building on the successes of the past 18 months and ensure that Celtic remain competitive at the highest level.
If Rodgers can continue to lead Celtic to further success in the Champions League and maintain domestic dominance, his second spell at the club could be viewed as one of the most successful in Celtic’s history. In the end, it is the results on the pitch that will define Rodgers’ tenure, and so far, he has delivered in spades.
Sport nation
Sport Nation 2
