Sport nationBrendan Rodgers’ Second Spell at Celtic: A Story of Redemption and Triumph
When Brendan Rodgers returned to Celtic for a second stint as manager, not everyone was convinced it was the right move. The way he left the club in 2019 to join Leicester City left many Celtic fans feeling betrayed. Rodgers had been the architect of an unprecedented period of success, leading the club to back-to-back trebles and overseeing an invincible domestic season. However, his sudden departure during the crucial stages of the 2018/19 season left a bitter taste for many supporters.
Fast forward to today, and it seems most Celtic fans have let bygones be bygones. Rodgers, now 18 months into his current contract, has not only steadied the ship after Ange Postecoglou’s departure but has also elevated the team’s performances to new heights. With the possibility of qualifying from the Champions League group stages and another domestic treble within reach, the Northern Irishman has undoubtedly won over many of his critics.
Celtic legend Martin O’Neill, who knows the pressures of managing the Glasgow giants all too well, recently shared his thoughts on Rodgers’ second spell. Speaking on The Go Radio Football Show, O’Neill praised Rodgers for overcoming initial skepticism and delivering results on the pitch. “Oh, he’s doing splendidly, really,” said O’Neill. “And yes, he had a lot to overcome. There’s no doubt about that.”
This article delves into Rodgers’ journey during his second tenure at Celtic, examining the challenges he faced, the progress he has made, and how his legacy at the club is evolving.
The Context: Rodgers’ Return and Fan Backlash
Brendan Rodgers’ return to Celtic in 2023 came after Ange Postecoglou departed for Tottenham Hotspur. Postecoglou had been a hugely popular figure at Celtic Park, winning over fans with his high-energy football and securing a domestic treble in the 2022/23 season. His departure left a void that the Celtic board needed to fill quickly, and Rodgers, who was available after leaving Leicester City, emerged as the most viable option.
However, Rodgers’ appointment divided opinion among the Celtic faithful. Many fans were still harboring resentment over his abrupt exit in 2019, which they viewed as prioritizing personal ambition over the club. Chants of “You traded immortality for mediocrity” had echoed around Celtic Park in the wake of his departure, a reflection of the deep sense of betrayal felt by supporters.
Rodgers, for his part, acknowledged that he had unfinished business at the club. Upon his reappointment, he emphasized his commitment to restoring Celtic’s dominance in Scotland and making an impact on the European stage. It was clear, however, that he had a lot of work to do to win back the trust of the fans.
A Rocky Start: Rebuilding Trust and Momentum
Rodgers’ first season back at Celtic was always going to be a challenging one. Not only did he have to navigate the expectations of a demanding fanbase, but he also inherited a squad in transition. While the core of the team that won the treble under Postecoglou remained intact, key players like Jota and Carl Starfelt had moved on, leaving gaps that needed to be filled.
Celtic’s start to the 2023/24 season was mixed. Early exits in the UEFA Champions League qualifiers disappointed fans who had hoped for progress in Europe. Domestically, though, Rodgers quickly found his rhythm, guiding the team to the Scottish Premiership title and the Scottish Cup. While falling short of another treble, these achievements marked a solid foundation for Rodgers to build upon.
Martin O’Neill reflected on this period, noting, “He had a lot to overcome. There’s no doubt about that. Coming back, I think there were people he had to win over. And finally, you win people over by performances, by results.”
The Turning Point: Champions League Success and Domestic Dominance
The 2024/25 season has seen Brendan Rodgers take Celtic to another level. After bolstering the squad in the summer transfer window, Celtic have emerged as a force to be reckoned with, both domestically and in Europe. Key signings, including a reinvigorated central defense and an attacking midfielder to replace Jota, have added depth and quality to the squad.
Celtic’s performances in the Champions League have been particularly impressive. The 2-1 victory over RB Leipzig at Celtic Park was a standout moment, showcasing the team’s tactical discipline and attacking prowess. Martin O’Neill highlighted this game as a turning point: “The manner of their victory against Leipzig was brilliant. That’s as good a performance as I’ve seen in Europe for quite some considerable time.”
Domestically, Celtic have been in scintillating form, leading the Scottish Premiership table and remaining unbeaten in all competitions. The team’s attacking style of play, combined with defensive solidity, has drawn comparisons to Rodgers’ first spell at the club.
Comparing Rodgers’ Two Tenures at Celtic
Rodgers’ first spell at Celtic was defined by unprecedented success. In the 2016/17 season, he led the team to an invincible treble, going unbeaten in all domestic competitions. Over the course of his first tenure, Celtic won seven trophies in two and a half seasons, including two domestic trebles.
While replicating this level of dominance is a tall order, Rodgers’ second spell has been impressive in its own right. Here’s a statistical comparison of his performance across both tenures:
| Season | Played | Won | Drawn | Lost | Goals For | Goals Against | Trophies |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2016/17 (First Tenure) | 56 | 46 | 8 | 2 | 150 | 50 | Domestic treble |
| 2023/24 (Second Tenure) | 50 | 35 | 7 | 8 | 121 | 56 | Scottish Premiership & Scottish Cup |
While the 2023/24 season didn’t match the invincibility of his first year, Rodgers has shown that he can adapt to different circumstances and rebuild a winning team.
Fan Sentiment: From Skepticism to Support
Winning over the Celtic fanbase was never going to be easy for Brendan Rodgers. However, his ability to deliver results on the pitch has gradually silenced many of his critics. The team’s improved performances, particularly in Europe, have rekindled a sense of pride among supporters.
Rodgers’ willingness to engage with fans and acknowledge past mistakes has also played a role in rebuilding trust. In interviews, he has spoken candidly about the challenges of returning to Celtic and his determination to leave a positive legacy.
Martin O’Neill summed it up perfectly: “You win people over by performances, by results, and in the manner in which they’re playing now.”
Looking Ahead: Can Rodgers Secure Another Treble?
As the 2024/25 season progresses, the question on everyone’s mind is whether Brendan Rodgers can guide Celtic to another domestic treble. With the team firing on all cylinders, the possibility is certainly within reach. However, challenges remain, particularly in maintaining consistency and managing the physical demands of competing on multiple fronts.
In Europe, Celtic’s progression from the Champions League group stage would be a historic achievement, marking a significant step forward for the club. Success on this stage would further solidify Rodgers’ reputation and enhance his legacy.
Legacy and Redemption
Brendan Rodgers’ second spell at Celtic is shaping up to be a story of redemption. While his first tenure set an incredibly high bar, his ability to return to the club, rebuild trust, and deliver results speaks volumes about his character and managerial acumen.
For a manager who once left Celtic under a cloud of controversy, Rodgers now stands on the brink of achieving something truly special. If he continues to deliver success on the pitch, his second spell could ultimately be remembered as fondly as his first.
As Martin O’Neill rightly pointed out, “Brendan has done splendidly.” The Celtic faithful, once skeptical of his return, are now witnessing the resurgence of their club under his guidance.
Sport nation
