In an unexpected turn of events, West Ham United secured a hard-fought 2-0 victory against Newcastle United at St. James’ Park on November 25, 2024. Goals from Tomas Soucek and Aaron Wan-Bissaka not only silenced the home crowd but also relieved mounting pressure on manager Julen Lopetegui, whose future at the club had been in question due to poor performances in the Premier League.
The match surprised many, including veteran broadcaster Jeff Stelling, who admitted live on talkSPORT that he underestimated West Ham’s midfield trio of Lucas Paquetá, Carlos Soler, and Tomas Soucek. “When I looked at that West Ham midfield that started with Paquetá, Soler, and Soucek, I thought this was going to be a battering,” Stelling remarked. “But how wrong I was. They all did great—Soler, in particular, was terrific.”
A Crucial Win for Lopetegui
The victory against Newcastle marked a pivotal moment for Lopetegui, whose tenure at West Ham has been riddled with challenges. Before the match, the team had only managed four wins in 14 league games, raising doubts about his ability to lead the club forward. The Guardian had even reported that Lopetegui’s future depended on the outcomes of matches against Newcastle and Arsenal.
The win not only lifted West Ham six points clear of the relegation zone but also showcased the resilience and determination that had been missing in recent weeks. Despite Newcastle dominating large portions of the game, West Ham’s midfield trio and defensive line stepped up to secure the clean sheet and deliver a much-needed win.
The Role of the Midfield Trio
West Ham’s midfield trio played a vital role in the victory. Lucas Paquetá was named Sky Sports’ Man of the Match for his dynamic performance, while Tomas Soucek not only scored but also provided defensive stability. Carlos Soler, whom Stelling had doubted before the match, earned widespread praise for his composure and work rate in the midfield.
Soler’s performance was particularly notable as he adapted to the physicality and tempo of the Premier League, effectively countering Newcastle’s attacking threats led by Alexander Isak, Anthony Gordon, and Joelinton. The Spanish international’s ability to balance defensive duties with creative play contributed significantly to West Ham’s success.
Lopetegui’s Growing Challenges
Despite the victory, Lopetegui’s position at the club remains precarious. His tenure has been overshadowed by inconsistent performances and off-field controversies, including a recent dispute involving former Spain and Barcelona defender Gerard Piqué.
Piqué accused Lopetegui and then-national team captain Sergio Ramos of pressuring him to apologize publicly for his support of the 2017 Catalonia referendum. According to Piqué, Lopetegui even prepared a written statement for him to read during a press conference. Lopetegui, however, has categorically denied these allegations, claiming that it was Piqué’s decision to hold a press conference to clarify his stance.
The controversy has drawn significant attention in Spain, adding to the scrutiny Lopetegui faces both as West Ham manager and a former national team coach.
Building Momentum
As West Ham prepares for their next match against Arsenal, Lopetegui will hope the victory over Newcastle serves as a turning point. The result highlighted the team’s ability to dig deep and grind out a win despite the odds—a trait that has been sorely lacking this season.
The match against Arsenal will be another test of the team’s resilience and Lopetegui’s tactical acumen. A positive result could further alleviate pressure on the manager and provide a foundation for a more consistent run of form.
Defensive Resilience
West Ham’s defensive line, led by Kurt Zouma and Nayef Aguerd, was instrumental in keeping Newcastle at bay. Despite the home side creating multiple chances, the Hammers’ backline maintained their composure, blocking key attempts and ensuring that goalkeeper Alphonse Areola was well-protected. Wan-Bissaka’s goal was the cherry on top of an impressive defensive performance, reflecting the team’s determination to contribute at both ends of the pitch.
Positive Signs for the Future
The victory against Newcastle showcased a West Ham side capable of overcoming adversity. The midfield trio’s performance, in particular, offered a glimpse of the team’s potential when firing on all cylinders. Paquetá’s creativity, Soucek’s physicality, and Soler’s composure provided a balanced approach that proved effective against a formidable Newcastle side.
The win also emphasized the importance of squad depth and adaptability. With January’s transfer window approaching, Lopetegui will need to address areas of concern, including bolstering the squad’s defensive and attacking options.
A Controversy to Resolve
While the on-pitch performance has brought some respite, Lopetegui must also navigate the fallout from Piqué’s allegations. The accusations have put the manager under intense scrutiny in Spain, overshadowing his efforts to stabilize West Ham’s season.
Piqué’s comments have reignited debates about the intersection of politics and football, particularly in Spain, where the Catalonia independence movement remains a divisive issue. For Lopetegui, addressing these allegations head-on may be necessary to clear his name and refocus on his managerial responsibilities.
Looking Ahead
West Ham’s win against Newcastle provides a platform for Lopetegui and his team to build upon. With tough fixtures ahead, including the clash against Arsenal, consistency will be key to climbing the league table and ensuring long-term stability.
The manager will hope to leverage the newfound confidence within the squad, particularly the cohesion displayed by the midfield trio. If the team can replicate the determination and discipline shown at St. James’ Park, there’s every chance they can turn their season around.
As for Jeff Stelling, his revised opinion on Carlos Soler serves as a reminder of the unpredictable nature of football. Soler’s performance against Newcastle has silenced critics and demonstrated his value to the team, further validating Lopetegui’s trust in the midfielder.
In a season full of challenges, West Ham’s victory over Newcastle is a beacon of hope—a testament to what the team can achieve when they play to their potential. Whether this marks the start of a resurgence under Lopetegui remains to be seen, but for now, the Hammers have shown they are up for the fight.