Sport Nation 2Everton’s 2024/25 Premier League campaign has been anything but smooth, with persistent struggles casting a shadow over the club’s hopes for stability. Under manager Sean Dyche, the Toffees initially appeared to recover from a dismal start, only for new challenges to emerge, leaving fans questioning the club’s direction.
A Troubling Start
The season opened disastrously for Everton, with consecutive losses and defensive collapses marking their early matches. Despite these setbacks, a brief period of improvement suggested the team might have found some footing. Wins like the one against Ipswich offered hope that the worst was behind them. However, recent performances have shown a troubling stagnation.
In their last four fixtures, Everton managed three draws and a loss, all against mid-table or lower-ranked sides: Fulham, Southampton, West Ham, and Brentford. Collecting just three points from such matches has left them precariously positioned. The inability to capitalize on these “winnable” games now looms large, given the daunting fixtures that lie ahead.
December: A Month of Nightmares
The holiday season could prove pivotal for Everton’s fortunes, as they face one of the most challenging fixture lists imaginable. December kicks off with a trip to Manchester United. Although United are in transition under new leadership, even this is considered one of Everton’s “easier” matches in a grueling schedule.
What follows is a series of high-stakes encounters: a critical six-pointer against Wolves, then consecutive clashes with Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea, and Manchester City. By Boxing Day, Everton will have faced almost all of the Premier League’s elite. Adding to their woes, they close out the year with a tricky fixture against Nottingham Forest.
A Bleak Start to 2025
The new year brings no respite. Everton will begin January against Bournemouth before tackling Aston Villa, Tottenham, and Brighton in rapid succession. This relentless schedule could leave the club in dire straits, with relegation fears becoming more pronounced if results don’t improve quickly.
Dyche Under Pressure
Sean Dyche’s tenure at Everton has been a mixed bag. Known for his ability to achieve solid results with limited resources during his time at Burnley, Dyche has struggled to replicate that success at Goodison Park. While he managed to shore up the team’s defense after a series of early thrashings, this has come at the cost of attacking flair. Everton have gone from conceding too many goals to scoring far too few, leaving them unable to secure vital wins.
The fanbase’s frustration is palpable. Many are questioning Dyche’s tactics and his ability to inspire a squad that, on paper, has more potential than its current results suggest. With the club’s trajectory appearing bleak, calls for change are growing louder. However, even if Everton were to replace Dyche, the timing presents a challenge. The tough run of fixtures offers little room for a “new manager bounce,” potentially delaying any meaningful turnaround.
Nostalgia for David Moyes
In their search for solutions, some fans have turned to nostalgia, expressing a desire for the return of former manager David Moyes. Moyes, who led Everton from 2002 to 2013, is fondly remembered for bringing stability and overachievement to the club during his tenure. His ability to consistently secure top-half finishes and occasional European football made him a fan favorite.
However, the suggestion of Moyes’ return also reflects the deep-seated anxiety within the Everton fanbase. While Moyes’ past achievements are undeniable, relying on a managerial reunion in 2024 seems like a step backward, born more out of desperation than strategic planning.
Ownership and Future Direction
Adding to Everton’s struggles is the uncertainty surrounding the club’s ownership and financial situation. With persistent rumors of managerial replacements and the prospect of significant changes behind the scenes, stability feels like a distant goal. New owners reportedly considering names like José Mourinho and Graham Potter to replace Dyche have only added to the speculation.
Everton’s long-standing financial challenges and recent brushes with relegation have amplified the pressure on those at the helm. The club’s leadership must navigate these turbulent times carefully, balancing short-term survival with long-term rebuilding.
The Risk of Relegation
For a club of Everton’s stature, the prospect of relegation is almost unthinkable. Yet, recent seasons have seen the Toffees repeatedly flirt with the drop. This year, their failure to capitalize on a relatively forgiving early fixture list could come back to haunt them. With just 11 points from 12 matches, Everton’s margin for error is slim as they head into the toughest part of the season.
The consequences of relegation would be devastating—not just financially but also in terms of the club’s reputation and ability to retain key players. It would mark a dramatic fall from grace for one of England’s most historic football institutions.
What Needs to Change?
To avoid disaster, Everton must find a way to reignite their attacking play without sacrificing defensive solidity. Striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin, once a reliable source of goals, has struggled for form and fitness, leaving the team without a consistent goal threat. The January transfer window may offer an opportunity to strengthen the squad, but whether the club will have the resources or allure to attract quality signings remains uncertain.
Additionally, Dyche must address the team’s lack of identity on the pitch. His reputation for building cohesive, hard-working units has not translated effectively at Everton. If he cannot instill a clearer tactical vision soon, his tenure may come to an abrupt end.
The Role of the Fans
Amidst the gloom, Everton’s loyal fanbase remains a crucial factor in the club’s fight for survival. Goodison Park has long been known for its passionate atmosphere, and the supporters will need to rally behind the team during this challenging period. However, patience is wearing thin, and the club’s leadership must act decisively to restore faith.
A Long Road Ahead
As the festive season approaches, Everton find themselves at a crossroads. The coming weeks could define not just their season but also their immediate future as a Premier League club. While football’s unpredictability means there’s always a chance for a turnaround, the current trajectory offers little cause for optimism.
For now, Everton’s fans can only hope that their team defies expectations and finds a way to navigate the storm. If not, the Toffees may face yet another grim chapter in their storied history—a prospect that no one at the club wants to contemplate.
Sport nation
Sport Nation 2